Solida Crankset - Broken Once Again - The Velo Collective

 

Solida Crankset Woes

 

I’ve had problems with Solida cranks before. Not that I don’t like Solida cranksets, or have it in for them, they are pretty nice looking cranks and are as lightweight as the best of them. Yet, they must be cheaply made, because I’ve come across three of them now that have ended up in the bin. The first one developed a crack on the drive side arm; the second, well, let’s just say it crumbled to pieces; this, the third, had something of a different problem, a hidden issue. That all reminds me of the great scene in Monty Python’s Holy Grail:

 

 

 

In the Shadow of the Galaxy

 

The crankset was installed on a recent purchase, which was a 1982 Dawes Horizon. For all of you unfamiliar with classic British bikes, the Horizon was the cheaper alternative to the Dawes Galaxy, the most famous British tourer. You could say it was the inferior sister to the rather smug and haughty Galaxy, and was always in its shadow, forgotten about, ignored. Damn that Galaxy! This Solida crank was functioning fine on the Horizon, but was absolutely filthy.

 

Image of Dawes Horizon bike

The Dawes Horizon with a New Crank

 

Removing the Solida Crankset

 

The only way to clean the crank was to remove it from the bike, because you have to believe me, it was so bunged up with greasy dirt it couldn’t have been cleaned on the bike. It’s the stuff that can’t been cleaned off with a hose or a spray. It’s clogs up everything, and just smears when you rub it. Now, things began fine: I took off the dust cap and crank bolt off easily and without any strain. But then, something strange happened. On turning the crank puller tool, the crank just, well.. fell off. No torque was needed to remove it whatsoever.

 

Image of Solida crankset rear side

The Rear Side

 

What Happened Next

 

I should have realised it then, but I just thought it was my lucky day, there was no hernia-inducing effort to get this crank off. I cleaned the drive side thoroughly, taking off the chain rings, polishing the metal, and let me say that it took me a good hour to get this thing looking clean. But now came the undoing of all my good work: the crank wouldn’t tighten back on the bottom bracket spindle. I was looking at it absolutely bewildered, like I must have been losing my mind. How could it not go back on? My thoughts turned to the spindle: yes, it has to be the spindle.

 

Close up image of irregular bolt hole

The Problem

 

I was Wrong

 

Looking back, I thought I was quite stupid not to have seen the problem. Yet, it is quite a trick this crank played on me. You could even say it was devious. The square hole for the crank bolt, if you look closely, is no longer square. It has worn into a slightly irregular shape, and so the spindle rattles in it, wobbles even when the bolt is tightened with massive torque. Have you ever come across that? I haven’t before, and I must have installed hundred of cranks. So, hats off to Solida once again, for defeating me with an unfixable problem. Damn you!

 

Image of irregular Solida crankset with illustration

The Irregular Sides

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This